Post

Destroy the walls we build ourselves

For my first presentation in our new journal club, I didn’t stick to my lab-meeting habit of focusing on my own small niche. Instead, I chose a paper in Science that fits the name of my degree, Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, perfectly.

What first made me want to read it closely was the word “platform”, which appears in both the title and the abstract. I assumed it meant something like the concept our close collaborators like to invoke, like a regulatory role carried out by a large platform built from many proteins and nucleic acids. If so, a close reading might help us describe and define that kind of platform function in our own work.

Once I started reading properly, I found that the “platform” here is a rather smaller concept, a complex formed by several subunits. It wasn’t what I had expected, but the paper used quite a few methods I had never come across, so many of the figures couldn’t be understood at a glance. I found myself gripped by a kind of curiosity growing stronger when it seemed harder to understand quickly, so I read on with real interest.

One striking feature of the paper is that there is no clear line between its wet-lab and dry-lab work. In the projects I’ve been involved in, one side always leads. Sometimes it is the dry lab: extensive, wide-ranging data mining comes first, then one or two hits are picked from thousands of results and handed to collaborators for wet-lab validation. Sometimes it is the wet lab: a hypothesis is drawn from the literature or from a chance observation in the lab’s earlier work, followed by a long series of reductionist single-factor interventions to look at phenotypes, with a few rounds of omics sequencing and analysis slotted in as supporting data. Papers produced either way leave a sense of a clear divide between wet and dry. The two sides do not build on each other step by step to move the research forward; one side sets the premise, and the other is asked to supply evidence for it. However hard everyone tries to package the work as a smooth, complete chain of logic when writing it up, the disconnect still shows.

About three years ago, I told my supervisor that I wanted to conduct a project in which every technique, whatever its kind, served simply as a tool, with no distinction between them, used only as the research naturally required. He turned the idea down, saying it wasn’t the data-driven mindset a bioinformatician should have. Having read this paper, though, I am more convinced than ever that turning a mere difference in technique into a barrier within science is simply a way of limiting ourselves. Bioinformatics and biotechnology were both developed as tools to serve particular research goals. There should be no true barriers between them at all.

At this point a rather more conspiratorial thought occurred to me. Over the years I’ve often heard fellow students say, “That’s the bioinformatics part” or “That’s the experimental part, I don’t understand it,” and then stop exploring and simply wait for collaborators to provide some superficial validation. Could academia be building these barriers on purpose, quietly fixing the way people think so that they naturally learn to avoid anything outside their own field? Would that shrink the number of people who fully understand research and can carry out thorough and comprehensive studies, keeping that ability in the hands of a few? Perhaps that thought is a little too dark, though.

Still, I don’t want to end up like other students, lack a more systematic way of thinking. That is why, whenever I came across a new method in this paper, wet or dry, I read as much as I could to understand its principles, how it is carried out, and how its results are interpreted. I may not use this knowledge any time soon, but keeping it in the back of my mind might give me a better sense of direction the next time I want to explore a scientific question, and a clearer idea of which techniques to turn to for answers.

Reading this paper also showed me how much I genuinely love learning. Over the past several months I often wondered whether I still enjoyed research and whether I could keep going down this path. Working through this paper made me realise that I still very much enjoy discovering new things through research. What gave me the illusion of burnout is more likely my environment: no freedom to explore, no means to resist formulaic research, no reliable collaborators, and being stuck on the fringes of an academic world grown cliquish and bureaucratic, unable to move forward or step back. And the immersive joy of exploring doesn’t seem enough to dissolve the exhaustion and helplessness this environment leaves me with.

How I should carry on from here remains, for me today, a mystery.

slides

This post is licensed under CC BY 4.0 by the author.

Trending Tags